Aaron Rodgers, Steelers rumors and the old ‘he’s gay’ punchline that won’t die
John Casey has now watched Pittsburgh Steelers fans question whether 2 of their quarterbacks are gay, but only once they began to decline.

Editor’s Note: This article originally appeared on Outsports in December 2025.
I grew up in Pittsburgh during the 1970s, when the Steelers were stacking their then-record four Super Bowl wins.
I’ve been away from the city for more than 30 years, but I haven’t lost my passion for the Steelers. Don’t talk to me on a Monday morning after they’ve lost.
Back in those glory days, Pittsburgh had a quarterback controversy when Terry Bradshaw was nearly dethroned by Joe Gilliam, who was Black. Many believed — Gilliam included — that he failed in Pittsburgh because of his race.
I still remember hearing racial comments, including one seared into my memory: “If Bradshaw is dumb, Gilliam must be dumber.” You didn’t need to read between the lines to understand the discrimination behind it.
It was sickening, especially because Gilliam was supremely talented. After leaving the NFL, he fell on hard times and died 25 years ago.
Get off the sidelines and into the game
Our weekly playbook is packed with everything from locker room chatter to pressing LGBTQ sports issues.
Subscribe to our Newsletter today
Two years after Gilliam’s passing, in 2002 another Black quarterback — Kordell Stewart — was benched by coach Bill Cowher despite taking the Steelers to two AFC Championship Games.
Some blamed race. Others blamed something else entirely.
I heard it firsthand: Friends from back home told me Stewart faltered because he was gay. Rumors and baseless speculation about his sexuality were everywhere.
Related
Former Pittsburgh Steelers QB Kordell Stewart’s story is why Outsports has avoided spreading gay athlete rumors
Outsports has received gay rumors about athletes for years, including Kordell Stewart. Though that trend is declining.
At a time when I wasn’t fully comfortable with my own sexuality, I didn’t rush to defend him. I even piled on. It was wrong.
Yet quietly, I was furious that being gay was treated as an explanation for bad play.
Now it’s happening again, this time with another Steelers quarterback who has endured his own wave of baseless gay speculation: Aaron Rodgers.
Aaron Rodgers is aging. It has its effects.
After an impressive start, particularly for someone over 40, Rodgers has looked miserable the last few weeks, both on the field and on the sidelines.
Yet again, some of my friends have revived the same old, tired punchline. After last week’s game, a friend messaged me: “Gay guys should stick to kicking.” He was ostensibly joking.
This time, I didn’t play along.
Related
Aaron Rodgers’ gay rumor explanation still makes no sense, when he abandoned his gay teammate
Aaron Rodgers rejected his gay friend and college teammate when rumors surfaced. He wants to rewrite history.
Rodgers has said he isn’t gay. Same with Stewart. And even if either of them were, it has nothing to do with how they perform. If we’re going to pretend Rodgers’ sexuality explains his poor play, then it should also explain the 65,000+ passing yards, 500+ touchdowns, four league MVP Awards and that Super Bowl ring.
Blaming an athlete’s sexuality, real or imagined, for his success or failure is childish and lazy.
Stewart showed flashes of brilliance, but he couldn’t sustain it over the long haul, whether in Pittsburgh, Chicago or Baltimore. That’s not about identity. It’s about the brutal NFL reality that fairy-tale careers are few and far between.
Aaron Rodgers is simply at the end. He just turned 42. He thought he could conjure some late-career magic in Pittsburgh after the mess in New York, but age and injuries are now his biggest obstacles, and it’s hard to bounce back from both of those.
Last week’s loss to the Buffalo Bills, with a broken wrist and a shockingly lackluster team around him, was the moment Rodgers’ miracle run was grounded, just like one of his passes.
At 6–6, the Steelers have a big game Sunday against the Baltimore Ravens and a loss would be damaging to any hopes of the playoff berth. They could even — gulp — suffer their first losing season in 18 years.
For Aaron Rodgers, that’s no way to make an exit from the league.
Subscribe to the Outsports newsletter to keep up with your favorite out athletes, inspiring LGBTQ sports stories, and more.
Mark