Hunter Schafer gets real about bottom surgery, dating & cis expectations

Trans women don't owe you disclosure

Hunter Schafer gets real about bottom surgery, dating & cis expectations
Cathy Hutchins//Shutterstock

This year, Hunter Schafer shared with audiences that she got bottom surgery in December, and she’s never felt better. “[It] was amazing, and I love it so much,” the trans trailblazer and Blade Runner 2099 star told Elle last month.

Schafer didn’t need to share that information, but fans are thrilled she did. The choice to get bottom surgery is, for many trans women, more complex than it might seem. But for those who choose to go through it, it can open up a new world of confidence and make certain tricky dating scenarios a lot less awkward.

In an old Call Her Daddy clip that’s currently recirculating, Schafer talks about how cis people often have bizarre expectations for trans women in the dating realm that are rooted in transphobia.

How about we take this to the next level?

Subscribe to our newsletter for a refreshing cocktail (or mocktail) of LGBTQ+ entertainment and pop culture, served up with a side of eye-candy.
Subscribe to our Newsletter today

“I’ve had hookups before with… cis women where they wanted me to f*ck them or something, like a guy, because I have a d*ck.”

That’s not a problem for Schafer any longer, but that doesn’t mean it’s not still an issue trans women have to face in an already-complicated dating environment. Between cis ignorance and the many toxic expectations around disclosure, it can be difficult to navigate.

Another trans icon has spoken about this issue at length. Last year, after Laverne Cox’s call-in, Ts Madison and Cox spoke about the challenges that trans women—especially Black trans women—face in the dating scene, whether or not they’ve had bottom surgery. This August, Cox and Madison reconvened, and the conversation got even deeper.

“I don’t talk about the details of my medical transition,” Cox explained. “I think that is community talk. I think that conversation objectifies trans people and dehumanizes them.”

Cox has always taken a hard line when it comes to the invasive, ignorant questions leveled at trans women celebrities by the press—we still haven’t forgotten that incredible Katie Couric shut down!

But Madison has a different relationship to transition talk.

“I really want people, when they view me… there’s been this big thing with trans people, the first narrative with trans people…is ‘I was trapped in the wrong body.'”

“I hate that sh*t,” Cox agrees. Madison explains that she wants to combat that idea, as well as challenge the assumption that trans people all hate their genitals. “If I want a p*ssy,” she says, “I will get a p*ssy.”

“I think people are surprised,” Cox says, “that many trans women don’t want bottom surgery.”

The bottom line here is—surprise!—trans women are not a monolith. But when it comes to the expectations of cis people, dating can get very complex very quickly.

That doesn’t mean that there isn’t room to learn and grow—provided cis people do that learning on their own time, not while they’re actively trying to date trans women. As Schafer says in the clip, there are some cis people who instantly “get it.” But there’s also a lot of conflicting information out there—not to mention general bad faith misinformation—that gets it twisted.

There’s also, thanks to Tr*mp’s attack on trans people, a growing societal expectation to get bottom surgery just in order to pass and be safe in a transphobic world.

Madison brought this reality up on the Jason Lee show this summer. “I thought about [getting bottom surgery] just recently, when Tr*mp got elected,” Madison explained. “This sh*t is crazy out here. This sh*t get rough.”

As we’ve seen, of course, even passing doesn’t necessarily mark you safe from transphobia and discrimination whether in public or in the bedroom. Anti-trans attacks have ended up hurting cis women and girls, and will continue to make the world less safe for women of all identities. Which is exactly why it’s important that icons like Schafer, Madison, and Cox continue to talk about their experiences—provided they feel comfortable enough doing so. There’s room in our world for all kinds of bodies, all kinds of transness, and all kinds of self-love. The only thing that needs to change are cis expectations—and anti-trans legislation.

Related

What happens when bisexual panic threatens to tear a marriage apart?
Biphobia is everywhere

Sign up for the Queerty newsletter to stay on top of the hottest stories in LGBTQ+ entertainment, politics, and culture.