Was gay life better in the ’90s and ’00s? The internet has thoughts

A man has prompted debate by asking if gay life was better in the 1990s and ’00s.

Posting in the AskGayBrosOver30 subreddit, he said, “I’m 32, so I obviously didn’t really experience gay life during the 90s or most of the 2000s. I grew up in a relatively conservative, industrial city where gay life basically didn’t exist. I remember being in school and there was pretty much one openly gay boy, and he was constantly made fun of. Things obviously got better with time. I think, generally speaking, gay people today are much more accepted and respected than we were decades ago.

“But something I keep thinking about is whether gay social life itself was actually richer back then.”

He says that once he began traveling, he began to hear about the gay scene of previous decades: “More bars, clubs, bathhouses and places where you could simply show up and meet other gay men.”

How about we take this to the next level?

Subscribe to our newsletter for a refreshing cocktail (or mocktail) of LGBTQ+ entertainment and pop culture, served up with a side of eye-candy.
Subscribe to our Newsletter today

“Today I live in a major city, and there is definitely still gay nightlife. But when older people describe what existed before, the difference sounds enormous.”

Spartacus

He says that he recently came across an old copy of the gay guide, Spartacus. The annual publication was launched in 1970 but went fully digital around ten years ago.

“I looked up the city where I live now, and it was kind of shocking. In one particular gay area, the guide listed something like 12 gay bars; I think today there are maybe two.

“Do you think gay life was socially richer in the 90s and 2000s?” he asked. “In terms of community, friendships, nightlife and meeting people organically, was there something that we actually lost?”

HIV/AIDS

Many people responded. Some reacted more to the headline “Was gay life actually better in the 90s and 2000s?” and were quick to point out the many downsides of gay life in the 1990s and 2000s.

Chief among these was AIDS, and the fact that gay couples could not marry in most of the US.

“Nope! From a gay perspective, the 90s were the peak of the HIV/AIDS crisis!,” was one of the most well-liked replies. Medication didn’t arrive until the mid-90s, and even then, early drugs “had severe side effects.”

As for the lack of equal marriage rights, they added, “The effects were severe: Estranged parents had the right to decide about you in case you are not responsive in the hospital, your lifetime partner had no rights. Not even to visit you!”

Another said, “The bars may have been more crowded and we may have been more fired up, but it’s because we were angry and had no rights. Life is objectively better in most places in 2026, especially where I live in the US.”

Others pointed out that HIV tests used to take up to two weeks to yield a result, or that “gayborhoods like Wilton Manors were generally affordable still and not yet become places where only rich gays could afford to live.”

“A real loss”

The original poster clarified that he was just asking whether gay social life was better in the 90s and 00s. People responded with a more mixed opinion on this.

One man said he came of age in 1990 in Boston and he agreed the internet decimated bars: “But that started way before Grindr, and even way before smartphones. Bar attendance started to wane when sites like Craigslist started to take off, and people could hook up and meet other people without ever leaving the house. Smartphone apps only accelerated that.

“This summer I went back to Boston with my husband, and every place I used to go to was gone,” except for one, “which was a shabby shell of what it used to be. Now it’s kind of a dump. It’s not just bars, but all the places are gone – the gay gym I used to go to is gone, the gay bookstore is gone, the coffee shops are all gone. I think there was one new bar that I didn’t recognize when I hunted around on my phone, but the total number of places to go is much smaller. That feels like a real loss.”

Many others agreed that the bar scene of the 90s and 00s was lit. One suggested that apps took some of the people away who were just seeking hookups, but left those wanting to dance or socialize.

“As an elder millennial, I only started going out and getting comfortable in the clubs in the 2010’s, was very active and went out to the clubs/bars till almost 2018. It was really fun and for the most part, I don’t think Grindr ruined things; if anything, it took away the people who were there only for predatory purposes.”

“When we blew off steam, we really blew off steam”

Another said that gay men partied hard as a way to let off steam.

“If by social life, you mean city culture, going out, etc., then yes. Sorry, but it was [better], especially the 90s. I worked at The Roxy and Sound Factory. That time and those clubs basically blow everything today out of the water. Back then, AIDS was still cutting a swath through the gay population, the majority of mainstream culture hated all of us, and it was in its own way, a more politically active time on the grassroots level. So when we blew off steam, we really blew off steam.”

However, others resisted looking back at the 80s and 90s through rose-tinted glasses.

One man in his early 60s said, “If you really, really, really enjoyed going to the funerals of friends, the 80s and 90s gay social life was perfect for you.”

“I don’t need that ‘safe space’ as much now”

Others said it’s easy to look back and only remember the fun one had in one’s youth.

“Older people can be quite nostalgic,” said a man in his late 60s. “After all, we were younger, hotter and more energetic then. And it is just human to forget about bad things that happened in the past.

“I remember the thrill of walking into a gay bar in the 80s and 90s … surrounded by guys just like me. I don’t get that thrill now. Part of it is that older. But it is also more routine. I don’t need that ‘safe space’ as much now because society is far more accepting, and that’s a good thing.”

Nobody is disputing that there were many more queer bars back in the 1990s, but many said they wouldn’t want to go back in time, given the lack of equality and acceptance across society back then.

Do you think gay social life was better back then? Or does the digital age offer other ways to connect, beyond just hooking up? Let us know below.

Related

WATCH: Russell Tovey & Tom Blyth sizzle in ’90s-set cruising cop thriller ‘Plainclothes’
A simmering romance wrapped in a paranoid thriller, the film explores what happens when an officer assigned to bait & bust cruisers falls for one of his marks.

WATCH: This ‘90s news clip by Network Q throws it back to Stonewall’s 25th anniversary
Self-proclaimed as “too queer for cable,” Network Q was originally distributed to viewers nationwide via VHS tapes before being picked up by a select few public television stations.

Sign up for the Queerty newsletter to stay on top of the hottest stories in LGBTQ+ entertainment, politics, and culture.