‘New Fire Island’ founders announce they’ve chosen their location

They want to build a new residential village on a Greek island.

‘New Fire Island’ founders announce they’ve chosen their location
A man boards a boat in Greece
A man boards a boat in Greece (Photo: GeoGayphoto8/Shutterstock.com)

The team behind the ‘New Fire Island’ project has announced that they’ve settled on a location to build a new, queer-oriented vacation village.

If you’re unfamiliar with the whole idea, it first went viral a couple of years ago. A group of investors announced that they wished to create a unique, gay vacation hotspot. A belief that Fire Island Pines, Provincetown and Key West have become overly expensive for vacationers and those wishing to buy property partly drove the initiative.

“We’re bringing together a community of gay men to build a new paradise, inspired by the original Fire Island Pines – in the sunny Mediterranean and for a new era,” said a statement on the New Fire Island website.

They say that, unlike the US, “Europe doesn’t have a walkable, purpose-built gay holiday escape.”

Pack your bags, we’re going on an adventure

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter for the best LGBTQ+ travel guides, stories, and more.
Subscribe to our Newsletter today

They invited people to register for more details. Thousands did so.

They say they’re hoping to offer homes at around US $500,000 “for a four-bedroom freestanding house with a pool, in gay paradise.”

Syros

The leadership team appears to be headed by Australian architect Nigel Smith.

Over the weekend, Smith posted a video to announce the location for the project.

​​After two years of searching over 10,000km of Mediterranean coastline, and walking away from 31 other sites, “this is the one. Sixty-five hectares on the pristine island of Syros,” he said, adding that it includes, “a beachfront, a private peninsula, 40 minutes by boat to international flights, and from where I’m standing, nature all around you.”

Syros is a Greek island in the Cyclades, in the Aegean Sea. It is 78 nautical miles southeast of Athens. International visitors to Syros often fly via nearby Mykonos, a short ferry ride away. Syros also has a domestic airport and excellent fast ferries to Athens, Santorini, Crete, among other destinations.

Ano Syros, Syros
Ano Syros, Syros (Apostolos Mantzouranis/Shutterstock.com)

The capital of Syros is Ermoupoli, with a population of around 12,000. It also has the picturesque smaller town of Ano Syros, which offers a panoramic view of the neighboring islands of Tinos, Delos, Mykonos, Paros, Andros and Naxos. The island offers a number of secluded coves, beaches and areas of potential redevelopment.

A beach on the Greek island of Syros
A beach on Syros (Photo: Georgios Antonatos/Shutterstock)

Offer accepted

“Our offer for this land has been accepted,” Smith continued. “We have our U.S. sponsor company to complete the transaction, and we are inviting a limited number of founders into it. Four gentlemen have already made a commitment. The Greeks have a word for when something is just the way it’s meant to be accomplished and precious. They say, telios. This is telios.”

Smith has previously said that the New Fire Island name was likely to be changed once they settled on a location. Perhaps “Telios” is it?

The official website carries artists’ impressions and brochures of several properties the team wishes to build on the site. GayCities has reached out to Smith for more information.

The New Fire Island
Aerial view (artist’s impression/New Fire Island)
A design for a 'Garden Villa' at the New Fire Island project
A design for a ‘Garden Villa’ at the New Fire Island project
A design for a 'Courtyard Townhouse' at the New Fire Island project
A design for a ‘Courtyard Townhouse’ at the New Fire Island project

Building from scratch

When the project was first announced, some people expressed skepticism that a new gay hotspot could be built from scratch. Fire Island and Provincetown grew organically over decades, first tending to attract artists and then an LGBTQ following.

How confident do the team feel that such a location can be created by design?

“We love the history of P’town and Fire Island,” a spokesperson told GayCities’ sister site, Queerty, in 2024.

“We now live in the TikTok era where word travels fast and wide, and what’s more, we now have hard-fought rights that generations before gained for us. This makes the rapid creation of a gay escape very possible amongst the global gay village.

“In terms of design, we are co-creating New Fire Island as a deeply intentional community with those people who express interest in buying land. So, we are very confident that we can create this community in no time at all.”

That said, nothing involving physical construction happens overnight. This bold initiative may still take years to reach fruition.

UPDATE 11.18.26

Nigel Smith contacted us with some further comments after our story was published.

“As per the video, we are in negotiations to purchase the site. The community we’ve built helped choose it and is helping fund the purchase. New people are coming on board.

“The Syros site meets all our community’s criteria. While there are many details, in summary:

  • sense of escape and close to international flights
  • a private valley well sized for a small town
  • sandy west facing beach, long swimming season, and long overall season
  • easy access to health, education, and construction services
  • few environmental, archaeological, or planning issues, and a clear pathway to approval
  • a strong sense of place – this is driven by the proud culture and vibrant community of the people of Syros

“We will be closing the ‘Founder’s Circle’ before Christmas.”

Related

This gaggle of guys wants to build a “New Fire Island” & there’s already a waitlist
What do you make of this idea?

This sexy Greek daddy can teach you everything you need to know about Athens
We traveled to Greece to find the best of Athens.

Join the GayCities newsletter for weekly updates on the best LGBTQ+ destinations and events—nearby and around the world.