That time the NFL turned two Bucs fans gay on Mad TV

The 2003 Mad TV sketch 'A Football Thing' still gets laughs today, as well as airtime in gay bars throughout the country.

That time the NFL turned two Bucs fans gay on Mad TV

If you watched TV sketch comedy in the 1990s and early 2000s, chances were pretty good that you’d eventually encounter the “pop culture but turn it gay” premise.

It was clearly a favorite of Saturday Night Live alumni of that era, from Chris Farley’s classic Schmitt’s Gay beer commercial parody to Robert Smigel’s playful Ambiguously Gay Duo cartoons.

Unlike a lot of mainstream comedy from that era, these sketches weren’t mocking gay people as an easy punchline but were satirizing straight tropes by adding a gay twist to them.

Related

This gay couple is featured in ESPN’s new series about Dallas Cowboy fans
Justin and Tim are about to become husbands. They are two gay men in love and in love with the Dallas Cowboys as NFL fans.

On November 1, 2003, SNL’s competitor Mad TV added their contribution to the “turn it gay” bit with a sketch called “A Football Thing.”

Get off the sidelines and into the game

Our weekly playbook is packed with everything from locker room chatter to pressing LGBTQ sports issues.
Subscribe to our Newsletter today

Centered around two fans of the reigning champion Tampa Bay Buccanneers, “A Football Thing” cast sketch comics Ike Barinholtz and Josh Meyers as two passionate superfans celebrating Bucs highlights in front of their TV.

After a few seconds of exposition where they both reference meeting their girlfriends’ parents, the sketch begins with a Bucs touchdown sending Barinholtz and Meyers into the kind of testosterone-fueled frenzy we’re used to seeing in the stands of every football stadium in the country.

Yelling quickly turns into high fives. 

Which escalate into a chest bump. 

And that leads into a full-groping makeout session that lasts for almost ten seconds as the studio audience explodes.

Tampa Bay Super Bowl win inspired Mad TV gay fans

For context, a few months prior, the Buccaneers defeated the Oakland Raiders to win Super Bowl XXXVII. Yet there’s not a single play from that game that will stick in your mind more than the image of Barinholtz and Meyers celebrating a Bucs touchdown with the kind of passionate kisses that are normally accompanied by a Sufjan Stevens soundtrack.

At first, the two try to rationalize their moment of passion. “It was just a thing! It’s a football thing! It happens all the time!” claims Meyers. It leads to this very early-2000s exchange…

Barinholtz: So…are we gay?
Meyers: No!…I don’t know…were you excited?
Barinholtz: NO!…Yes. A little bit. I was a little bit excited. Does that make me gay?
Meyers: NO!…Yeah. A little bit. A little bit gay.

There’s a nice moment where the audience gives an applause break to Barinholtz’s first “NO!…Yes” punchline. It was not a given that crowds of that era would enjoy comedy about two closeted gay football fans that didn’t descend into cruel mockery and these cheers had to make the two comics feel like they’d done something right.

Their moment of contemplation is interrupted by the Bucs recovering a fumble, causing the two to begin another celebration and…well, you can probably see where the rest of the sketch is going. 

Multiple times.

It holds up well because the punchline attacks the masks of masculinity that Barinholtz and Meyers feel they have to adopt as part of their football fan personas.

Related

Hockey hero Hilary Knight’s ‘SNL’ appearance a first for out LGBTQ athletes
Knight likely became the first out LGBTQ athlete to appear on ‘Saturday Night Live’ last weekend.

But because it was handled so well, “A Football Thing” lived on for years following Mad TV’s cancellation. As a 2017 interview with Barinholtz by LGBTQ editor Brandon Voss revealed, a few gay bars soon picked up the sketch and began adding it to their video monitor rotations.

Their performances even give the characters a little depth to the point where you almost feel bad that they can’t be honest about their attraction to each other. Which, to be fair, might simply be a product of deciding to write a thinkpiece about a five minute comedy sketch 23 years after it aired.

“Honestly, you’re probably about the 15th, 16th person to tell me about their hometown gay club playing that sketch,” Barinholtz said, “It’s the greatest thing. What’s better than having smart, attractive consumers looking at you all night?”

Thanks to “A Football Thing,” Barinholtz got to experience a little glimpse of what it feels like to be Ariana Grande. As comedy bits go, that’s a pretty good legacy.

Subscribe to the Outsports newsletter to keep up with your favorite out athletes, inspiring LGBTQ sports stories, and more.