DC Circuit panel rejects Trump request to restart dismissal of trans military personnel

On Nov. 17, a three-judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit rejected the government’s motion to be allowed to continue discharging transgender military service members while it seeks review by the Supreme Court. Technically, the government was asking that the DC Circuit delay sending its “mandate” from a June decision … Read More

DC Circuit panel rejects Trump request to restart dismissal of trans military personnel
On Nov. 17, a three-judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit rejected the government’s motion to be allowed to continue discharging transgender military service members while it seeks review by the Supreme Court. Technically, the government was asking that the DC Circuit delay sending its “mandate” from a June decision in Talbott v. United States to the district court. In its June decision, the panel voted 2-1 to uphold the district court’s injunction against Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth’s policy, which he had adopted to effectuate a Trump executive order to dismiss all transgender military personnel regardless of their service records. By a different 2-1 vote, however, in June the panel reversed the district court’s injunction concerning Hegseth’s policy forbidding the enlistment of new transgender personnel. The three members of the panel are Circuit Judge Robert Wilkins (an Obama appointee), Circuit Judge Justin Walker (a Trump appointee), and Senior Circuit Judge Judith Rogers (a Clinton appointee). The majority to affirm the district court’s injunction against discharges consists of Judges Wilkins and Rogers. Judge Walker dissented in part from the June opinion, joining with Judge Wilkins to overturn the injunction regarding enlistment. On Nov. 17, Judges Wilkins and Rogers joined to order the Clerk of the court to “issue the mandate forthwith,” putting finality on the decision regarding discharges unless the Supreme Court grants a petition by the government to review the case. The panel did not issue an opinion, but Judge Wilkins wrote a detailed statement explaining his vote. Judge Walker did not write a dissent but signified that he would grant the government’s motion. Judge Rogers agreed with the Order without comment, although she had partially dissented from the June decision, arguing that the court should have affirmed the district court’s injunction relating to enlistments as well as discharges. Judge Wilkins’ explanation for his vote was that the government had failed to show one of the prerequisites for the relief it was seeking: that it would suffer an irreparable injury if the Defense Department could not discharge transgender personnel while the government is seeking Supreme Court review. Indeed, the government’s only argument in support of its motion boiled down to effectuating the policy preferences of President Trump as expressed in his executive order. “In its motion,” wrote Judge Wilkins, “the government has not alleged any irreparable harm that will result from retention of the currently serving Plaintiffs — decorated servicemembers who have ‘served honorably’ while meeting ‘all military standards during their service.’ Instead of contesting these facts, the government generically asserts that our mandate required the military to ‘implement a policy’ that it believes ‘poses substantial risks' to an effective national defense.’ But the Department has never specified — before the District Court, on appeal, or now in its motion to stay — what national security 'risks' will follow from retaining the serving Plaintiffs. Yet that is all our mandate requires.” The government’s position throughout this lawsuit is that transgender service members should be discharged because that is what the President has ordered. But wrote Wilkins, “To the extent the government suggests that any injunction against the executive branch imposes irreparable harm, I am also unpersuaded. Such a ‘broad and seemingly novel proposition’ is untethered to both this Court’s and the Supreme Court’s longstanding practice. As we have repeatedly said, irreparable injury must be both ‘certain and great,’ ‘actual and not theoretical.’” The government was also arguing that the Supreme Court’s decision earlier this year in West Virginia v. B.P.J., in which the Supreme Court held that schools may restrict eligibility for women’s and girls’ sports based on biological sex, required the court in this case to reconsider its equal protection analysis. Judge Wilkins disagrees with that proposition, stating that the government “misunderstands both B.P.J. and this Panel’s holdings,” and pointed out that the Supreme Court’s B.P.J. opinion holds “open the possibility of heightened scrutiny for transgender classifications.” Significantly, the Supreme Court has yet to rule directly on whether the government’s discrimination based on gender identity must be tested under the heightened scrutiny standard, which requires the government to prove that its policy substantially advances an important public interest. If the Supreme Court ultimately grants the government’s petition to review the Talbott case, it may finally be called upon to decide this key issue, which it has fought shy from doing in the past.