Boy in girls field hockey plays for his 3rd straight state title amid growing controversy
Ryan Crook is a boy who will play for his third straight Massachusetts high school girls field hockey state title this Saturday.

When the Massachusetts high school girls field hockey state finals take place this Saturday, there will be one on-field element likely to draw plenty of conversation: a boy player.
Ryan Crook will take the field for Somerset Berkeley High School when they play against Nashoba Regional for the Division 2 state championship on Saturday. Crook has led the team to the last two state titles.
Crook has been the South Conference MVP for girls field hockey the last two seasons. His older brother, Lucas Crook, helped Somerset Berkeley win two Division 1 state titles when he was in high school, in both 2018 and 2019.
Related
Hockey star was ‘ready to give up’ on Olympics before falling in love with his prime minister boyfriend
Nico Keenan says his boyfriend Dutch PM Rob Jetten was ‘the safety net’ he needed to come out publicly and still pursue his hockey dream at the Olympics.
Their mother, Jen Crook, is the head coach of the team. The only state titles she and Somerset Berkeley have won in her 31 years coaching have been when one of her sons was playing on the team, earning hear at least one coach of the year award.
This year, the Somerset Berkeley team has stormed through the MIAA playoffs, beating its four opponents by a combined score of 24-2, including a 3-1 drubbing of the top-seeded Canton. Their opponent on Saturday, Nashoba, has won its four playoff games by a combined 13-0.
Get off the sidelines and into the game
Our weekly playbook is packed with everything from locker room chatter to pressing LGBTQ sports issues.
Subscribe to our Newsletter today
The Crooks have declined to talk about the issue of a boy — the best player on his team now with over 200 career points — playing on a girls team and on the brink of a fifth state girls title for the Crook brothers.
Yet there is plenty of chatter about it online from advocates of women’s sports, as well as anti-trans-athlete advocates (Crook is not trans but rather a cis boy).
The chatter includes, of course, Riley Gaines sharing a video of Ryan blowing past several female opponents, going coast-to-coast for a goal.
Massachusetts state rules allow boys to play girls field hockey
State rules in Massachusetts are clear: If a boy wants to play a sport not offered as a boys team by his school, he can play with the girls, all the way to the state championship.
While there is plenty of consternation about a boy playing on a girls team, there is also a lot of support in the interscholastic world of the Bay State and beyond.
Chip Rogers, an assistant field hockey coach at Miami (Ohio), is a long-time advocate of the sport. He’s in his eighth year as a board member for USA Field Hockey, now finishing a two-year term as board president.
Rogers has worked for years to build opportunities for boys and men like himself, in addition to girls and women, to play field hockey. He sees benefit to the MIAA rule allowing boys to play the sport he loves.
“I want there to be access for anyone to be able to play to play,” Rogers said, speaking as an individual in the sport. “If this is a bridge to allow us to create opportunities for boys to play, then I want that.”
Rogers has seen the opportunities in Massachusetts shift because of the rule allowing boys to play girls field hockey.
The hubbub over the topic has bubbled for years in the state. Lucas Crook’s back-to-back state titles in part led Massachusetts high school sports leaders to sanction 7v7 boys field hockey at the varsity level, to be played in the spring.
Yet in the five years since the state created the sport, not a single school has been able to field a team.
There are two main reasons.
The biggest hurdle for the growth of boys field hockey may be the stigma of field hockey being a “girls sport.” Schools have struggled to build programs because, akin to sports like figure skating and gymnastics, boys playing field hockey at the high school level are virtually guaranteed to be teased for simply participating.
Related
Olympians tell Outsports why it matters to be out lesbian players at the World Cup
Two Olympians tell Outsports they are proud to be part of ‘important’ LGBTQ representation at the Hockey World Cup.
“I don’t support the ridicule and demeaning of anyone who chooses to play our sport,” Rogers said. The Crooks brothers, as well as many other boys playing with the girls teams, have faced just that.
In addition to stigma, boys field hockey as a spring sport competes for athletes against established, popular boys sports of track and field, lacrosse, baseball, tennis and golf.
Still, Rogers is optimistic.
“I have high hopes we’ll create a system for 7v7 boys field hockey in Massachusetts,” Rogers said. In an ideal world for the longtime coach, boys wouldn’t be on girls teams, but would have their own space to play.
“I’d love for boys to have the opportunity to play in their own league. We just don’t have the numbers for it right now.”
Field hockey becoming a women’s sport in America
Men’s field hockey is popular in other parts of the world, particularly in certain countries including Netherlands, Pakistan, India and Malaysia.
Strong men’s national teams represent countries like Germany, Belgium, Australia and Argentina. Along with Netherlands, those are the top-five ranked countries in the world. Nico Keenan, one of the couple dozen out gay men competing at the 2024 Summer Olympics in Paris, plays for the Argentina team.
The United States is currently ranked No. 26 in the world on the men’s side. The American women are ranked No. 10.
When the sport came to the United States at the start of the 20th century, it was originally played mostly by men, because women were deemed too dainty to play.
Yet with the invention of basketball, volleyball and other sports around the same time, and the fast rise in popularity of football and baseball, by the 1940s men’s field hockey had all but disappeared in America.
As women increasingly sought a place for them in sports, field hockey emerged.
Now boys and men interested in playing field hockey struggle to find a place to play the sport they love. Massachusetts is the only state that now offers boys field hockey, and it’s also the only state that allows boys to play girls field hockey simply when there isn’t another opportunity to play the sport.
Akin to the Massachusetts rule, Pennsylvania gave boys broad latitude to play girls field hockey until 2014, with one boy — JaJa Kentwell, now on Team USA — helping his high school girls team win a state title in 2008.
Related
Teammates in love and world’s top goalkeepers lead 11 LGBTQ stars at World Cup
Charlotte Englebert and Emma Puvrez are couple goals in the Belgium squad at a home Hockey World Cup with strong LGBTQ representation.
Now the commonwealth joins New York and California with a path for boys to play girls field hockey, but that path is highly regulated and narrow.
“Athletics, especially at the high school level, should be about participation, bonding, personal growth and preparing students for the next phase of their life,” Rogers said. “That’s why I support interscholastic athletics.
“If we try to punish people seeking these opportunities, are we doing our jobs as educators and mentors in the community by allowing people to deny student-athletes the ability to play?”
MIAA continues support of boys’ opportunities in field hockey
In Massachusetts, Rogers estimated there are about 10 boys playing high school field hockey with the girls across the entire state each year. Other estimates put the number at 20 to 50 per year.
Until there are opportunities for boys, the longtime field hockey coach and player wants those opportunities to exist.
Still, one of those boys plays this weekend for a state title — his third straight. Depending on which number you lean on, anywhere from 2% to 10% of all the boys playing high school field hockey in Massachusetts will play in a state title game this weekend.
That about matches up with the girls playing the sport: About 4% of all the players in the state made it to a state final this year.
Rogers said his support for boys playing girls field hockey has its limits, saying he’d oppose any rule that allowed it at the NCAA level, with adult men playing adult women.
Regardless of the growing furor over boys playing in girls sports, the Massachusetts Interscholastic Athletic Association that oversees high school sports is unlikely, given the politics of Massachusetts, disallow boys like Ryan Crook from girls field hockey anytime soon.
Subscribe to the Outsports newsletter to keep up with your favorite out athletes, inspiring LGBTQ sports stories, and more.
Mark