‘The Fantasticks’: Classic romance with a same-sex twist

In 1960, a minuscule musical with an enormous heart called “The Fantasticks” opened at the Sullivan Street Playhouse in Greenwich Village. Against all odds, the beloved boy-meets-girl show, with book and lyrics by Tom Jones and score by Harvey Schmidt, ran for 21,000 performances. It is widely considered the world’s longest running musical. Over the … Read More

‘The Fantasticks’: Classic romance with a same-sex twist
In 1960, a minuscule musical with an enormous heart called “The Fantasticks” opened at the Sullivan Street Playhouse in Greenwich Village. Against all odds, the beloved boy-meets-girl show, with book and lyrics by Tom Jones and score by Harvey Schmidt, ran for 21,000 performances. It is widely considered the world’s longest running musical. Over the years, the show has logged in more than 11,000 productions across the US, plus countless runs on community and high school stages. And now, 66 years after the show debuted, “The Fantasticks” has finally landed on Broadway. Which begs the question: Can this charming, outmoded tuner — a surreal mix of fairytale, romance, and Commedia dell’arte — hold its own on a vast Broadway stage? And, more importantly, can it offer an invigorated take for modern, somewhat jaded audiences?  The answer is a resounding yes and yes. The patchy story, centering on teenaged next-door neighbors Matt and Luisa, whose fathers trick them into falling in love, was given a major gender overhaul. Luisa became Lewis. The fathers became mothers. Remarkably, Jones, in his 90s, was recruited to revamp the book, swapping out pronouns and dusting off cultural cobwebs. These bold changes have injected a fresh resonance and meaning to the narrative. Theatergoers unfamiliar with the original can be forgiven in assuming the play was conceived as a boy-meets-boy love story from the start.  [caption id="attachment_65820" align="aligncenter" width="700"]Zane Phillips in "The Fantasticks." Zane Phillips in "The Fantasticks."Joan Marcus[/caption] Under the direction of Christopher Gattelli (“Schmigadoon!”), this revamped “Fantasticks” feels perfectly at home at the Hayes Theater, the smallest Broadway house with roughly 600 seats. (The Sullivan Street Playhouse had about 150.) A clever framing device depicts the move from its modest initial home to its new Broadway digs. For instance, in flashback we see a harp player and a pianist, who comprised the original musicians. Now there’s a full orchestra. Gattelli also choreographed. Scenic designer Jason Sherwood has managed to retain the minimalist aesthetic of the original while crafting a gorgeous, otherworldly backstage tableau, with an assist by Jen Schriever’s lighting design. This emphasizes the allegorical nature of the material while celebrating the magic of theater. The ensemble is marvelous. Maxim Chlumecky brings a searing feistiness to Matt, whether he’s writing poetry while hiding up in a tree, or proclaiming his undying love for Lewis. Nathan Levy’s Lewis is a wide-eyed romantic who fantasizes an idyllic future with his beloved Matt. We see the male lovers passionately kiss, a rare sight on a Broadway stage. [caption id="attachment_65821" align="aligncenter" width="700"]The cast of "Fantasticks." The cast of "Fantasticks."Joan Marcus[/caption] Of course, a rosy future is not meant to be. After a blissful honeymoon period, embodied by a gleaming moon at night, the couple, and their mothers (the exuberant Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer and Ruthie Ann Miles), scrap and squabble in the harsh light of day. Matt abruptly leaves town to find greener pastures and to drink and gamble. Lewis stays put and seeks to have an affair. Matt perfectly expresses this sorry turn: “The plum is too ripe.” Is there hope for renewal and reconciliation? The limestone wall the mothers built to keep their sons apart is portrayed by “The Mute” (Ahmad Simmons), who artfully communicates through mime and dance. The wall stunt is actually a dose of reverse psychology, prodding the boys to “disobey” and get together. The cast is rounded out by Kevin Del Aguila and David Patrick Kelly, playing a variety of secondary roles. [caption id="attachment_65822" align="aligncenter" width="700"]Ahmad Simmons in "The Fantasticks." Ahmad Simmons in "The Fantasticks."Joan Marcus[/caption] True to the original, this outstanding reboot of “The Fantasticks” opens and closes with the soaring classic ballad, “Try to Remember,” belted out by El Gallo, the mystical narrator who guides us through their rocky journey. Zane Phillips, in his Broadway debut, plays the hunky trickster with an alluring machismo that is mesmerizing. No wonder Lewis is drawn to him while Matt is gallivanting across the countryside.  The Fantasticks | Second Stage | Hayes Theater | 240 W. 44th St. | $79 – $229 | Through February 7, 2026 | 2 hours with intermission